# TLDR Review: Physicians Formula Butter Blowout Mascara *Published: 2024-04-30 | Updated: 2024-05-19 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/physicians-formula-butter-blowout-mascara* --- ## Verdict The Physicians Formula Butter Blowout Mascara has its share of fans who appreciate its cruelty-free formulation, ease of application, and lovely fragrance. However, it tends to clump excessively for many users, overshadowing its volumizing promises. If you're a fan of lightweight, natural lash looks and enjoy a coconut scent, this might be up your alley. But if you're seeking dramatic length and reliable performance, you might be left wanting. Consider having a backup mascara if you're transitioning from their beloved Argan Oil line. **Top pro:** Cruelty-free formulation is a plus for conscious consumers. **Top con:** Many users experienced extreme clumping, making the mascara unusable. ## Product: Physicians Formula Butter Blowout Mascara **Brand:** Physicians Formula [Compare prices and price history on ShopSavvy](https://shopsavvy.com/products/physicians-formula-butter-blowout-mascara) ## Pros - Cruelty-free formulation is a plus for conscious consumers. - Pleasant coconut fragrance enhances the application experience. - The mascara applies easily, even without a magnifying mirror, and doesn't smudge on the eyelids. - Comb-like brush is effective at separating lashes and preventing clumps. - Buildable formula allows for both natural and dramatic looks. - Stays in place all day without smearing, even on oily skin. - Easy to remove with water, gentle on eyes, and contains beneficial ingredients. - Enhances natural eyelashes and provides a subtle, non-clumpy look. - Boldly enhances blonde eyelashes without looking unnatural. - Previous positive experiences with the brand due to gentle ingredients. ## Cons - Many users experienced extreme clumping, making the mascara unusable. - No noticeable lengthening effect on lashes despite multiple layers. - Some users disappointed with performance compared to previous Physician's Formula products. - Mascara may dry out quickly or have a small amount in the bottle. - Needs replacement every 3 months, doesn't last as long as hoped. - Some users long for the return of the Argan Oil formula, which was a favorite. ## Pros vs Cons at a Glance | Pros | Cons | |------|------| | Cruelty-free formulation is a plus for conscious consumers. | Many users experienced extreme clumping, making the mascara unusable. | | Pleasant coconut fragrance enhances the application experience. | No noticeable lengthening effect on lashes despite multiple layers. | | The mascara applies easily, even without a magnifying mirror, and doesn't smudge on the eyelids. | Some users disappointed with performance compared to previous Physician's Formula products. | | Comb-like brush is effective at separating lashes and preventing clumps. | Mascara may dry out quickly or have a small amount in the bottle. | | Buildable formula allows for both natural and dramatic looks. | Needs replacement every 3 months, doesn't last as long as hoped. | | Stays in place all day without smearing, even on oily skin. | Some users long for the return of the Argan Oil formula, which was a favorite. | | Easy to remove with water, gentle on eyes, and contains beneficial ingredients. | | | Enhances natural eyelashes and provides a subtle, non-clumpy look. | | | Boldly enhances blonde eyelashes without looking unnatural. | | | Previous positive experiences with the brand due to gentle ingredients. | | ## Last Seen Prices *Each price is the last one ShopSavvy observed, on 2024-12-05; it may have changed since.* | Retailer | Price | Availability | Last seen | |----------|-------|-------------|-----------| | [Amazon](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/d8a1041c-f781-14b2-f461-0e4b03d9fb00?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $10.31 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Physicians Formula](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/BaFaCo6G6mKDlQOaEm2c?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.49 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Walgreens.com](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/A81vHCHTKUlleu2jP8Qm?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.49 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Dillons](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/ebccfc11-2baa-2712-c2a3-c1f8c3775e39?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.88 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Fred Meyer](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/7c85fea4-4d65-549d-4d29-5563248355ff?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.88 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [King Soopers](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/66dffa37-d9db-955e-af21-44eed4bb6cb5?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.88 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Kroger](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/5d8900f3-2828-b9ac-c10a-125ca78f285a?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.88 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Smith's](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/61fab05e-679b-72f1-2427-f052536fadf8?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.88 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [CVS Pharmacy](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/8n2Ww2nLNpxTg4r3pLxT?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [GoSupps.com](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/m8O1EucU0O50GPAvrMnw?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $29.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [bigamart.com](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/1kzwCmBPtxPOije8s0FA/offers/1dfb8c15-55d2-d98c-c5a6-4a0cd4a20f96?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $41.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | [See every retailer and the full price history on ShopSavvy](https://shopsavvy.com/products/physicians-formula-butter-blowout-mascara) --- *About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data (each price shows when it was last seen).* *Machine-readable access: append `.md` to any ShopSavvy URL, or send `Accept: text/markdown`, to get this page as Markdown. For the same catalogue as structured JSON — product lookup by barcode/ASIN/URL, live prices across retailers, and price history — see ShopSavvy's MCP server at https://shopsavvy.com/agents and the Data API at https://shopsavvy.com/data.*