# TLDR Review: Organic Valley Salted Butter

*Published: 2025-01-23 | Updated: 2024-12-27 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/organic-valley-salted-butter*

---

## Product: Organic Valley Salted Butter
**Brand:** Organic Valley

## Pros
- Valued for its exceptional taste, often considered the best butter by some reviewers.
- Long-time users appreciate its flavor and have an emotional attachment.
- Ideal for low-carb dishes and found enjoyable in various culinary uses.

## Cons
- Significant dissatisfaction with the discontinuation of the cultured butter previously offered.
- The new non-cultured version is described as having an inferior taste and smell, sometimes described as foul.
- Complaints about the butter's color being almost white, raising questions about pasture-raising claims.
- Price increase despite the perceivable drop in quality from previous versions.
- Some batches, notably from specific lot numbers, are described as having an unpleasant smell when used for ghee.
- Strong preference and demand for the return of the previous cultured butter.

## Bottom Line

While Organic Valley Organic Butter has historically been praised for its flavor and versatility, the transition away from the cultured version has left many loyal customers disappointed. The new non-cultured formulation is often criticized for its taste, smell, and color. If you're seeking a cultured butter experience with better taste, you might consider looking into European styles known for higher butterfat content.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Valued for its exceptional taste, often considered the best butter by some reviewers. | Significant dissatisfaction with the discontinuation of the cultured butter previously offered. |
| Long-time users appreciate its flavor and have an emotional attachment. | The new non-cultured version is described as having an inferior taste and smell, sometimes described as foul. |
| Ideal for low-carb dishes and found enjoyable in various culinary uses. | Complaints about the butter's color being almost white, raising questions about pasture-raising claims. |
|  | Price increase despite the perceivable drop in quality from previous versions. |
|  | Some batches, notably from specific lot numbers, are described as having an unpleasant smell when used for ghee. |
|  | Strong preference and demand for the return of the previous cultured butter. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Walmart | $7.98  | Check |
| Reasor's | $7.99  | Check |
| Postmates | $8.29  | Check |
| Boxed Greens | $8.49  | Check |
| FreshDirect | $8.99  | Check |
| Instacart | $8.99  | Check |
| Sprouts | $8.99  | Check |
| Uber Eats | $8.99  | Check |
| Boxed Market | $9.49  | Check |
| OPIE Drive-Thru Grocery | $10.59  | Check |
| Good Eggs | $10.99  | Check |
| DoorDash | $11.49  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*