# TLDR Review: Oatey 31166 Hardware Sealer

*Published: 2024-10-02 | Updated: 2024-10-02 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/oatey-31166-hardware-sealer*

---

## Product: Oatey 31166 Hardware Sealer
**Brand:** ‎Oatey

## Pros
- Essential for various plumbing tasks such as sealing frames, faucets, strainer baskets, and fixtures.
- Waterproof seal makes it excellent for use between rigid surfaces.
- Adequate 14 oz volume for multiple uses.
- Comes in a handy jar, which is easy to store and use.
- Provides a reliable and durable seal that lasts long.

## Cons
- Can be messy to apply initially.
- Users may find it challenging to remove excess putty.
- Requires practice to perfect the application process for best results.
- Not suitable for use on plastic materials, which may limit its applications.

## Bottom Line

Oatey Plumber's Putty is a highly-effective, durable sealing solution perfect for various plumbing tasks, especially with metal surfaces. While it might take a bit of practice to get the application right, the robust seal it provides makes it worth the effort. For users needing more versatility in material compatibility, exploring other products could be beneficial.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Essential for various plumbing tasks such as sealing frames, faucets, strainer baskets, and fixtures. | Can be messy to apply initially. |
| Waterproof seal makes it excellent for use between rigid surfaces. | Users may find it challenging to remove excess putty. |
| Adequate 14 oz volume for multiple uses. | Requires practice to perfect the application process for best results. |
| Comes in a handy jar, which is easy to store and use. | Not suitable for use on plastic materials, which may limit its applications. |
| Provides a reliable and durable seal that lasts long. |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Inmyhomco | $0.90  | Check |
| My Store | $1.25  | Check |
| My Store | $1.50  | Check |
| Fleet Farm | $1.69  | Check |
| Blain's Farm & Fleet | $1.70  | Check |
| Supply Online | $1.70  | Check |
| WWCSupply.com | $1.73  | Check |
| Shell Lumber and Hardware | $1.75  | Check |
| SupremeDIY.com | $1.75  | Check |
| Cable Ranch | $1.76  | Check |
| MID Hardware | $1.77  | Check |
| WebstaurantStore.com | $1.89  | Check |
| Myhomco | $1.95  | Check |
| ThePaintStore.com | $1.96  | Check |
| After Hours Auto Parts | $1.99  | Check |
| Auto Parts and Stuff | $1.99  | Check |
| Rural King | $1.99  | Check |
| Store Seven | $1.99  | Check |
| UpStart Auto Parts | $1.99  | Check |
| Zoro Tools Industrial Supplies | $2.05  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*