# TLDR Review: NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry

*Published: 2026-01-22 | Updated: 2026-01-22 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/nyx-butter-lipstick-big-cherry*

---

## Product: NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry
**Brand:** NYX

## Pros
- The true bright cherry red of Big Cherry matches expectations and delivers a bold, classic lipstick color.
- Smooth, buttery soft texture that glides on comfortably without drying out lips.
- Moist finish offers a natural, creamy look rather than a flat matte.
- Lasts several hours and leaves a subtle, attractive stain on the lips.
- Cruelty-free brand supporting ethical beauty choices.
- Applies precisely due to the pointed lipstick shape, allowing for neat application.
- Gentle and moisturizing formula, suitable even for sensitive or dry lips.
- Pairs well with dark red lip liners without bleeding.
- Offers excellent pigmentation and shade variety for the price.
- Many users appreciated the lipstick for making a strong lip statement with a stylish black cherry/burgundy color.

## Cons
- Significant transfer occurs since the finish doesn’t dry down matte, requiring frequent touch-ups.
- Leaves a noticeable stain on glasses, so careful application is advised.
- Some color discrepancies reported, with shades appearing different (e.g., color looks more hot pink or lighter than expected).
- May need multiple applications to build up an even, vibrant color.
- A few users reported slight dryness, recommending exfoliation and balm use before and after application.
- Lighter shades like nudes and pinks may not perform as well as the deeper colors.
- Despite the long-lasting claim, reapplication every 2-3 hours is necessary for full intensity.
- Some disappointment versus hype, with users wanting to try other shades for better results.

## Bottom Line

The NYX Butter Lipstick in Big Cherry offers a vibrant, moisturizing, and cruelty-free option for those craving a classic bright cherry red with a creamy finish. While it does require some upkeep due to transfer and occasional dryness, its smooth application and lasting stain make it a solid choice for a bold lip look. If you seek a truly matte and transfer-proof lipstick, you might want to explore other formulas, but for a comfortable wear with a natural sheen, this one hits the mark. Considering the price and pigmentation, it’s worth trying, especially if you like a moisturizing, easy-to-wear lipstick.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| The true bright cherry red of Big Cherry matches expectations and delivers a bold, classic lipstick color. | Significant transfer occurs since the finish doesn’t dry down matte, requiring frequent touch-ups. |
| Smooth, buttery soft texture that glides on comfortably without drying out lips. | Leaves a noticeable stain on glasses, so careful application is advised. |
| Moist finish offers a natural, creamy look rather than a flat matte. | Some color discrepancies reported, with shades appearing different (e.g., color looks more hot pink or lighter than expected). |
| Lasts several hours and leaves a subtle, attractive stain on the lips. | May need multiple applications to build up an even, vibrant color. |
| Cruelty-free brand supporting ethical beauty choices. | A few users reported slight dryness, recommending exfoliation and balm use before and after application. |
| Applies precisely due to the pointed lipstick shape, allowing for neat application. | Lighter shades like nudes and pinks may not perform as well as the deeper colors. |
| Gentle and moisturizing formula, suitable even for sensitive or dry lips. | Despite the long-lasting claim, reapplication every 2-3 hours is necessary for full intensity. |
| Pairs well with dark red lip liners without bleeding. | Some disappointment versus hype, with users wanting to try other shades for better results. |
| Offers excellent pigmentation and shade variety for the price. |  |
| Many users appreciated the lipstick for making a strong lip statement with a stylish black cherry/burgundy color. |  |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*