# TLDR Review: Neutrogena Waterproof Mascara Black/Brown

*Published: 2026-02-05 | Updated: 2026-02-05 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/neutrogena-waterproof-mascara-blackbrown*

---

## Product: Neutrogena Waterproof Mascara Black/Brown
**Brand:** Neutrogena

## Pros
- Waterproof, smudgeproof formula that holds up well throughout the day
- Suitable for sensitive eyes with almost no irritation reported
- Applies smoothly without clumping for the most part
- Provides noticeable lash enhancement and lengthening, giving a natural look
- Available in soft black and brown-black shades with consistent color results
- Easy to use and provides better holding power compared to many other mascaras
- No strong scent, making it comfortable for sensitive users
- Some users noticed a visible lash extension effect after application

## Cons
- Difficult to remove without a dedicated makeup remover; regular cleansing can be a struggle
- Formula can feel dry and uncomfortable on the lashes, requiring multiple brush dips
- Some batches show inconsistent quality, leading to frustrations with application and performance
- Mascara can miss lashes and transfer onto eyelids or tissues during application
- Smears easily under the eyebrow with normal facial movement for some users
- Does not always coat lashes evenly or deliver the expected natural look for all users
- Clumping can occur occasionally despite overall smooth formula
- Some users would not repurchase due to removal challenges and formula texture

## Bottom Line

The **Neutrogena Healthy Volume Waterproof Mascara** delivers on key promises like waterproof wear, sensitivity-friendliness, and decent lash enhancement, making it a solid pick if you want a reliable, all-day mascara that won’t irritate your eyes. However, be prepared for some possible frustrations around removal and occasional formula dryness, which could impact your experience. If ease of removal and consistent smooth application are your top priorities, you might want to explore other waterproof mascaras with gentler removal or creamier formulas to suit your needs better.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Waterproof, smudgeproof formula that holds up well throughout the day | Difficult to remove without a dedicated makeup remover; regular cleansing can be a struggle |
| Suitable for sensitive eyes with almost no irritation reported | Formula can feel dry and uncomfortable on the lashes, requiring multiple brush dips |
| Applies smoothly without clumping for the most part | Some batches show inconsistent quality, leading to frustrations with application and performance |
| Provides noticeable lash enhancement and lengthening, giving a natural look | Mascara can miss lashes and transfer onto eyelids or tissues during application |
| Available in soft black and brown-black shades with consistent color results | Smears easily under the eyebrow with normal facial movement for some users |
| Easy to use and provides better holding power compared to many other mascaras | Does not always coat lashes evenly or deliver the expected natural look for all users |
| No strong scent, making it comfortable for sensitive users | Clumping can occur occasionally despite overall smooth formula |
| Some users noticed a visible lash extension effect after application | Some users would not repurchase due to removal challenges and formula texture |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Amazon | $7.47  | Check |
| Target | $8.99  | Check |
| beautysuppliers.org | $9.16  | Check |
| Zabiva.com | $9.76  | Check |
| Vitabox | $9.90  | Check |
| eCosmetics | $9.99  | Check |
| Rite Aid | $10.49  | Check |
| CVS | $11.49  | Check |
| CVS (photo) | $11.49  | Check |
| Walmart | $13.32  | Check |
| Fred Meyer | $14.43  | Check |
| Fry's | $14.43  | Check |
| King Soopers | $14.43  | Check |
| Kroger | $14.43  | Check |
| tracycosmetic | $14.94  | Check |
| Stoneberry | $14.99  | Check |
| EveryMarket | $18.99  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*