# TLDR Review: Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

*Published: 2026-02-05 | Updated: 2026-02-05 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/neutrogena-healthy-lengths-mascara*

---

## Product: Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara
**Brand:** Neutrogena

## Pros
- Gentle formula with no unpleasant smell, making it easy on sensitive eyes
- Contains vitamins that support natural lash growth, promoting healthier lashes over time
- Effectively separates lashes, delivering a natural, fresh, and beautiful look without clumping
- Comfortable to wear, even for those who experience irritation with other mascaras
- Easy to remove with regular face wash, avoiding discomfort or harsh rubbing
- Minimal smudging under the eyes, especially on lower lashes, maintaining a clean appearance
- Lightweight formula ideal for a subtle, no-makeup look
- Consistent and reliable performance typical of the Neutrogena brand
- Many users are satisfied enough to consider repurchasing

## Cons
- Not waterproof or suitable for heavy sweating, crying, or humid conditions
- Can rub off easily with just a slight touch, so not ideal for long-lasting wear
- Provides only moderate coverage and length, lacking drama or volume
- Some users find the performance disappointing compared to other mascaras, even within Neutrogena’s own line
- Does not deliver a glamorous or bold lash effect; more of a natural enhancement
- Users seeking significant volume or dramatic lashes may want to look elsewhere

## Bottom Line

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara is perfect if you want a gentle, natural-looking mascara that’s easy on sensitive eyes and promotes lash health. However, if you’re after more volume or long-lasting wear, this might leave you wanting. For those who need a bit more oomph or waterproof performance, consider trying another mascara with stronger volume or durability features instead.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Gentle formula with no unpleasant smell, making it easy on sensitive eyes | Not waterproof or suitable for heavy sweating, crying, or humid conditions |
| Contains vitamins that support natural lash growth, promoting healthier lashes over time | Can rub off easily with just a slight touch, so not ideal for long-lasting wear |
| Effectively separates lashes, delivering a natural, fresh, and beautiful look without clumping | Provides only moderate coverage and length, lacking drama or volume |
| Comfortable to wear, even for those who experience irritation with other mascaras | Some users find the performance disappointing compared to other mascaras, even within Neutrogena’s own line |
| Easy to remove with regular face wash, avoiding discomfort or harsh rubbing | Does not deliver a glamorous or bold lash effect; more of a natural enhancement |
| Minimal smudging under the eyes, especially on lower lashes, maintaining a clean appearance | Users seeking significant volume or dramatic lashes may want to look elsewhere |
| Lightweight formula ideal for a subtle, no-makeup look |  |
| Consistent and reliable performance typical of the Neutrogena brand |  |
| Many users are satisfied enough to consider repurchasing |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Amazon | $7.47  | Check |
| Target | $8.99  | Check |
| Vitabox | $9.90  | Check |
| eCosmetics | $9.99  | Check |
| Walgreens | $10.99  | Check |
| beautysuppliers.org | $11.07  | Check |
| Instacart | $11.29  | Check |
| CVS (photo) | $11.49  | Check |
| Fred Meyer | $14.43  | Check |
| Fry's | $14.43  | Check |
| King Soopers | $14.43  | Check |
| Stoneberry | $14.99  | Check |
| ibspot.com | $15.53  | Check |
| Kroger | $16.66  | Check |
| bigamart.com | $52.99  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*