# TLDR Review: Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker

*Published: 2025-05-18 | Updated: 2025-07-18 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/mr.-coffee-simple-brew-coffee-maker*

---

## Product: Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker
**Brand:** Mr. Coffee

## Pros
- Easy to use with a straightforward switch, no complicated programming needed.
- Water lines and glass pot markings are clear, facilitating simple measurements.
- Instructions are easy to understand for both brewing and cleaning.
- Versatile enough to be used for making tea.

## Cons
- The lid is difficult to open and doesn't fit securely, leading to spills and frustration.
- The decanter lid is flimsy, and issues with the seating mechanism obstruct coffee flow.
- Feels cheaply made with a design that requires careful handling.
- Operates loudly during brewing.
- Auto shut-off lasts only an hour, requiring manual intervention for extended use.
- Frequent malfunctioning reported, with some users finding reliability issues.
- New version lacks the quality and durability of previous models.

## Bottom Line

The Mr. Coffee Simple Brew 4-Cup Coffee Maker, Black seems to fall short of the brand's usual standards, with multiple reports highlighting its flimsy design, unreliable operation, and inconvenient features like the short auto shut-off. If you're in the market for a small coffee maker, you might want to consider the Kenmore 5 Cup Coffee Maker for its sturdier build and longer auto shut-off time. Additionally, many users report being disappointed enough to return the product given its various issues.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Easy to use with a straightforward switch, no complicated programming needed. | The lid is difficult to open and doesn't fit securely, leading to spills and frustration. |
| Water lines and glass pot markings are clear, facilitating simple measurements. | The decanter lid is flimsy, and issues with the seating mechanism obstruct coffee flow. |
| Instructions are easy to understand for both brewing and cleaning. | Feels cheaply made with a design that requires careful handling. |
| Versatile enough to be used for making tea. | Operates loudly during brewing. |
|  | Auto shut-off lasts only an hour, requiring manual intervention for extended use. |
|  | Frequent malfunctioning reported, with some users finding reliability issues. |
|  | New version lacks the quality and durability of previous models. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| ValleySeek | $13.88  | In Stock |
| Big Lots | $14.99  | In Stock |
| Toolbox Supply | $15.98  | In Stock |
| Reasor's | $21.99  | In Stock |
| Instacart | $23.39  | In Stock |
| Vanessa Jane | $24.00  | In Stock |
| Vitacost | $26.24  | In Stock |
| Walmart | $28.76  | In Stock |
| Killingworth True Value | $29.99  | In Stock |
| GoVets.com | $33.94  | In Stock |
| Max Warehouse | $33.95  | In Stock |
| VIP Outlet | $47.00  | In Stock |
| Newegg | $80.99  | In Stock |
| electroeshop.com | $81.29  | In Stock |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*