# TLDR Review: Milk & Cookies Ice Cream

*Published: 2026-05-06 | Updated: 2026-05-06 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/milk-and-cookies-ice-cream*

---

## Product: Milk & Cookies Ice Cream
**Brand:** Ben & Jerry's

## Pros
- Delicious ice cream with a satisfying combination of cookies and chocolate pieces
- Enjoyable flavor that feels like a guilty pleasure
- High-quality ingredients contribute to a rich and flavorful experience
- Well-balanced sweetness, not overly sugary
- Nostalgic childhood memories of milk and cookies evoke a comforting vibe
- Easy to enjoy without artificial notes, leaving a pleasant aftertaste
- Suitable for satisfying sweet cravings in a truly indulgent way
- Enjoyable enough to purchase multiple pints, highlighting its popularity
- The rich flavor makes it feel like a premium treat
- A good choice for those who love cookies and cream-style ice cream

## Cons
- Some may find it high in sugar and fat, making it an occasional indulgence rather than daily
- The flavor may be too rich or sweet for those preferring lighter options
- Wish for a larger size to enjoy more of it at once
- The presence of chocolate pieces and cookies can be cluttery for some, making it a bit messy to eat
- Not suitable for vegans or those avoiding non-GMO ingredients if strict dietary restrictions apply (though it is non-GMO, which many appreciate)
- No significant negatives noted, but some reviews suggest it’s indulgent enough to be too heavy for some

## Bottom Line

If you’re craving a nostalgic, rich, and indulgent vanilla ice cream with cookies and chocolate chunks, this Ben & Jerry’s flavor delivers with high-quality ingredients and a well-balanced sweetness. It’s perfect for a treat that feels like a true guilty pleasure, especially if you love cookie-inspired flavors. However, if you’re looking for a lighter or lower-sugar option, you might want to explore other brands or flavors.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Delicious ice cream with a satisfying combination of cookies and chocolate pieces | Some may find it high in sugar and fat, making it an occasional indulgence rather than daily |
| Enjoyable flavor that feels like a guilty pleasure | The flavor may be too rich or sweet for those preferring lighter options |
| High-quality ingredients contribute to a rich and flavorful experience | Wish for a larger size to enjoy more of it at once |
| Well-balanced sweetness, not overly sugary | The presence of chocolate pieces and cookies can be cluttery for some, making it a bit messy to eat |
| Nostalgic childhood memories of milk and cookies evoke a comforting vibe | Not suitable for vegans or those avoiding non-GMO ingredients if strict dietary restrictions apply (though it is non-GMO, which many appreciate) |
| Easy to enjoy without artificial notes, leaving a pleasant aftertaste | No significant negatives noted, but some reviews suggest it’s indulgent enough to be too heavy for some |
| Suitable for satisfying sweet cravings in a truly indulgent way |  |
| Enjoyable enough to purchase multiple pints, highlighting its popularity |  |
| The rich flavor makes it feel like a premium treat |  |
| A good choice for those who love cookies and cream-style ice cream |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Raley's Dev | $5.99  | Check |
| Publix Delivery | $6.31  | Check |
| Foxtrot UA | $6.49  | Check |
| Uber Eats | $6.88  | Check |
| Instacart | $6.89  | Check |
| FreshDirect | $6.99  | Check |
| Gopuff | $6.99  | Check |
| Mercato.com | $6.99  | Check |
| Boxed Market | $7.19  | Check |
| Minibar Delivery | $7.49  | Check |
| Foxtrot | $7.99  | Check |
| Greenwich Village Farm | $7.99  | Check |
| rehmie.com | $9.14  | Check |
| Realtruck | $194.48  | Check |
| TireBuyer.com | $220.00  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*