# TLDR Review: Member's Mark Almond Butter

*Published: 2026-08-27 | Updated: 2026-08-27 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/members-mark-almond-butter*

---

## Product: Member's Mark Almond Butter
**Brand:** MEMBER´S MARK

## Pros
- Offers a great flavor with natural roasted almond taste, without added sugar or artificial ingredients.
- Made with just almonds and salt, appealing to health-conscious consumers seeking a simple, clean product.
- Versatile for customizing with ingredients like flax seeds, chocolate, or vanilla to suit personal taste.
- Provides a good source of protein and healthy fats, making it a nutritious snack option.
- Stores well in the fridge after mixing, and can be optimized by using zip-lock bags for easier handling.
- Slightly oily consistency allows for pouring off excess oil for a thicker spread.
- Considered by some reviewers to be the best almond butter they've tried, surpassing other brands.
- No palm oil or artificial additives, catering to those avoiding processed ingredients.
- Suitable for people avoiding peanuts or palm oil-based products.
- Long-standing pantry staple with a trusted reputation among loyal buyers.

## Cons
- Shipping or delivery may lead to jars arriving unsealed or with open lids, risking product waste.
- The product has a coarse, gritty texture with large almond chunks, which may not appeal to everyone.
- Notably runny or creamy in its current form, requiring stirring or mixing before use.
- Separates over time, necessitating stirring or mixing with an electric hand mixer.
- Only available online now; no wider store presence, which limits easy access.
- The labeling's 'may contain' nut warnings raise questions about purity and authenticity as pure almond butter.
- Packaging during shipping is unreliable, with some reports of subpar handling affecting product quality.
- The unsealed jars and lack of convenient resealable containers can be inconvenient.
- Texture can be inconsistent, with some finding it too coarse or oily for preference.
- Requires effort and time to ensure proper mixing and consistency before consumption.

## Bottom Line

This Member's Mark Almond Butter offers a natural, flavorful experience for health-conscious consumers willing to put in a little extra effort for optimal texture. Its clean ingredients and versatility make it a good choice for recipes and customization. However, if convenience, smoothness, and reliable packaging are priorities, exploring other options with more consistent seals and textures might be beneficial.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Offers a great flavor with natural roasted almond taste, without added sugar or artificial ingredients. | Shipping or delivery may lead to jars arriving unsealed or with open lids, risking product waste. |
| Made with just almonds and salt, appealing to health-conscious consumers seeking a simple, clean product. | The product has a coarse, gritty texture with large almond chunks, which may not appeal to everyone. |
| Versatile for customizing with ingredients like flax seeds, chocolate, or vanilla to suit personal taste. | Notably runny or creamy in its current form, requiring stirring or mixing before use. |
| Provides a good source of protein and healthy fats, making it a nutritious snack option. | Separates over time, necessitating stirring or mixing with an electric hand mixer. |
| Stores well in the fridge after mixing, and can be optimized by using zip-lock bags for easier handling. | Only available online now; no wider store presence, which limits easy access. |
| Slightly oily consistency allows for pouring off excess oil for a thicker spread. | The labeling's 'may contain' nut warnings raise questions about purity and authenticity as pure almond butter. |
| Considered by some reviewers to be the best almond butter they've tried, surpassing other brands. | Packaging during shipping is unreliable, with some reports of subpar handling affecting product quality. |
| No palm oil or artificial additives, catering to those avoiding processed ingredients. | The unsealed jars and lack of convenient resealable containers can be inconvenient. |
| Suitable for people avoiding peanuts or palm oil-based products. | Texture can be inconsistent, with some finding it too coarse or oily for preference. |
| Long-standing pantry staple with a trusted reputation among loyal buyers. | Requires effort and time to ensure proper mixing and consistency before consumption. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Sam's Club | $6.98  | In Stock |
| My Kosher Cart | $8.72  | In Stock |
| Instacart | $8.86  | In Stock |
| Keanga | $9.28  | In Stock |
| GauchoMart | $9.57  | In Stock |
| Boxed.com | $9.98  | In Stock |
| Jarasim | $10.99  | In Stock |
| WholeAndNatural.com | $13.95  | In Stock |
| yummi2you.com | $13.95  | In Stock |
| truegether | $14.18  | In Stock |
| Grocery.com Store | $16.09  | In Stock |
| Walmart | $17.52  | In Stock |
| Groceryeshop | $18.35  | In Stock |
| openbax | $18.86  | In Stock |
| OTC Shoppe Express | $19.55  | In Stock |
| ShelHealth.Com | $23.02  | In Stock |
| opensky | $24.11  | In Stock |
| OliveTips.com | $39.65  | In Stock |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*