# TLDR Review: HP 58A Toner Cartridge

*Published: 2026-07-16 | Updated: 2026-07-16 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/hp-58a-toner-cartridge*

---

## Product: HP 58A Toner Cartridge
**Brand:** HP

## Pros
- High-quality cartridge made with durable materials ensuring long-lasting use
- Performs reliably and consistently delivers good print quality
- Easy to install, great for DIY users
- Provides vibrant, clear print output with sharp text
- Capable of printing a large volume of pages before needing replacement
- Offers good value considering its performance and longevity
- Fits perfectly in the compatible HP printers, ensuring hassle-free setup
- Well-regarded for meeting or exceeding user expectations
- Suitable for both casual and light professional printing needs
- Delivers consistent performance during extended use

## Cons
- The cartridge box appeared opened and resealed, raising concerns about its new condition
- Plastic container was not sealed and may have been previously used or returned
- Some users expressed dissatisfaction with receiving a potentially used or tampered product
- Not necessarily designed for heavy-duty or high-volume printing environments
- Limited feedback suggests some reviewers may have experienced minor print quality issues over time

## Bottom Line

Based on user reviews and product details, the HP 58A Black Toner Cartridge offers reliable, high-quality printing with long-lasting performance, making it a solid choice for most business and personal needs. However, potential buyers should be aware of concerns regarding packaging and ensure they purchase from reputable sources to avoid receiving a resealed or used item. If you need a fresh, unopened cartridge with peace of mind, considering other sellers or verified new products might be worth it.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| High-quality cartridge made with durable materials ensuring long-lasting use | The cartridge box appeared opened and resealed, raising concerns about its new condition |
| Performs reliably and consistently delivers good print quality | Plastic container was not sealed and may have been previously used or returned |
| Easy to install, great for DIY users | Some users expressed dissatisfaction with receiving a potentially used or tampered product |
| Provides vibrant, clear print output with sharp text | Not necessarily designed for heavy-duty or high-volume printing environments |
| Capable of printing a large volume of pages before needing replacement | Limited feedback suggests some reviewers may have experienced minor print quality issues over time |
| Offers good value considering its performance and longevity |  |
| Fits perfectly in the compatible HP printers, ensuring hassle-free setup |  |
| Well-regarded for meeting or exceeding user expectations |  |
| Suitable for both casual and light professional printing needs |  |
| Delivers consistent performance during extended use |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| My Store | $35.10  | In Stock |
| Multioculus.com | $91.70  | In Stock |
| ValueTekno | $97.00  | In Stock |
| Shopping.com | $99.99  | In Stock |
| Ready Office Supplies | $102.11  | In Stock |
| Green World Copier & Supplies | $104.00  | In Stock |
| Zerbee.com | $105.16  | In Stock |
| TonerBuzz OEM | $108.00  | In Stock |
| OfficeCurb | $108.83  | In Stock |
| IT Devices Online | $109.26  | In Stock |
| DeployDepot.ca | $109.33  | In Stock |
| TonerPirate.com | $110.19  | In Stock |
| BlueDogSupplies.com | $110.89  | In Stock |
| B&H | $110.99  | In Stock |
| Harper Office US | $110.99  | In Stock |
| hp (us) | $110.99  | In Stock |
| JourneyEd | $110.99  | In Stock |
| Corebuy | $114.66  | In Stock |
| Toner Laser Cartridge | $115.00  | In Stock |
| UnbeatableSale | $116.72  | In Stock |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*