# TLDR Review: HP 305A Toner Cartridges 3-Pack

*Published: 2025-06-11 | Updated: 2025-07-18 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/hp-305a-toner-cartridges-3-pack*

---

## Product: HP 305A Toner Cartridges 3-Pack
**Brand:** HP

## Pros
- Consistently reliable performance and high quality for color laser printers.
- Excellent quality toner cartridges that outperform generic brands.
- Essential for producing high-quality prints, such as greeting cards.
- The three-pack X-size cartridges offer the best value.
- Other color cartridges function normally, pointing to reliability outside the yellow cartridge issue.
- Competitively priced compared to other suppliers.

## Cons
- The yellow toner cartridge is not being accepted by the printer, causing frustration.
- Replacement yellow cartridges also result in error messages, hinting at persistent issues.
- Cartridge capacity is significantly lower than advertised, especially compared to the claimed 2500 pages.
- Magenta cartridge failed, indicating potential quality control issues.
- High cost of replacement cartridges is not justified by performance.
- Required to purchase multiple colors in one package, restricting flexibility and increasing cost.
- Online customer support has been ineffective and unhelpful.

## Bottom Line

While the HP 305A toner cartridges deliver excellent quality and reliability, especially compared to generic brands, there are notable issues with the yellow cartridge and discrepancies in expected versus actual page yield. The bundled packaging of colors also raises concerns for those who only require specific individual colors. If yellow cartridge issues persist, it may be worth exploring alternative products or contacting support for a resolution.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Consistently reliable performance and high quality for color laser printers. | The yellow toner cartridge is not being accepted by the printer, causing frustration. |
| Excellent quality toner cartridges that outperform generic brands. | Replacement yellow cartridges also result in error messages, hinting at persistent issues. |
| Essential for producing high-quality prints, such as greeting cards. | Cartridge capacity is significantly lower than advertised, especially compared to the claimed 2500 pages. |
| The three-pack X-size cartridges offer the best value. | Magenta cartridge failed, indicating potential quality control issues. |
| Other color cartridges function normally, pointing to reliability outside the yellow cartridge issue. | High cost of replacement cartridges is not justified by performance. |
| Competitively priced compared to other suppliers. | Required to purchase multiple colors in one package, restricting flexibility and increasing cost. |
|  | Online customer support has been ineffective and unhelpful. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| SupplyLinkUSA.com | $165.00  | Check |
| Bonanza | $258.62  | Check |
| Toner Graphics | $265.95  | Check |
| surplustoner.com | $278.52  | Check |
| Mercari | $284.00  | Check |
| ValueTekno | $314.00  | Check |
| Corebuy | $347.03  | Check |
| Tonerworld | $348.03  | Check |
| Arceto.com | $356.29  | Check |
| EliteWarehouse.com | $356.99  | Check |
| Wide Image Solutions | $356.99  | Check |
| Kawwi.com | $357.95  | Check |
| TradeInn USD | $372.99  | Check |
| TripleNetPricing.com | $374.32  | Check |
| DeployDepot.ca | $374.56  | Check |
| BlueDogSupplies.com | $374.89  | Check |
| Tech-America.com | $375.00  | Check |
| Multioculus.com | $376.87  | Check |
| Express-Inks | $379.99  | Check |
| Express-Inks | $379.99  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*