# TLDR Review: Holstein 5-Cup Coffee Maker

*Published: 2026-03-03 | Updated: 2026-03-03 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/holstein-5-cup-coffee-maker*

---

## Product: Holstein 5-Cup Coffee Maker
**Brand:** Holstein Housewares

## Pros
- Brews 5 cups, making it perfect for small households or two large morning servings.
- Stylish and vibrant teal color adds a fun, retro vibe that complements various kitchen decors.
- Compact size fits well in modern kitchens without taking up too much counter space.
- Comes with a built-in reusable coffee filter and coffee scooper, reducing the need for disposable filters and adding convenience.
- Compatible with Melitta #2 paper filters, giving users flexibility in their filter choice.
- Produces consistently great-tasting coffee with rich flavor from the first to the last cup.
- Easy to clean overall, with dishwasher-safe parts simplifying maintenance.
- Practical cord length allows flexible placement without clutter.
- Reliable brewing performance once you understand the water-pumping arm mechanism, which is clever though not immediately intuitive.

## Cons
- The glass coffee pot is fragile and prone to cracking over time; replacement pots are not sold separately, which can be frustrating.
- The coffee maker does not have an auto shut-off feature, which might be a safety consideration for some users.
- Wet coffee grounds tend to stick inside the reusable filter area, making cleaning more tedious and messy.
- Small amounts of leftover coffee often collect below the filter, causing occasional dribbling or mess if poured quickly.
- The user manual lacks clear explanation about the moving water-pumping arm mechanism, causing some initial confusion.
- The unit is very lightweight, which means it requires one hand to hold firmly while starting or stopping the machine to avoid spills.

## Bottom Line

The Holstein Housewares HH-0914701E 5-Cup Coffee Maker in teal is a charming, compact, and functional option if you want a small-batch coffee maker with a retro look and easy everyday use. It delivers solid coffee flavor and convenience with reusable filters, but be prepared to handle a delicate glass pot and some minor cleaning quirks. If the lack of auto shut-off or fragile pot concerns you, consider looking for models with enhanced durability or safety features. Overall, it’s a perfect pick for style-conscious coffee lovers who prioritize moderate capacity and ease of use over high-tech bells and whistles.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Brews 5 cups, making it perfect for small households or two large morning servings. | The glass coffee pot is fragile and prone to cracking over time; replacement pots are not sold separately, which can be frustrating. |
| Stylish and vibrant teal color adds a fun, retro vibe that complements various kitchen decors. | The coffee maker does not have an auto shut-off feature, which might be a safety consideration for some users. |
| Compact size fits well in modern kitchens without taking up too much counter space. | Wet coffee grounds tend to stick inside the reusable filter area, making cleaning more tedious and messy. |
| Comes with a built-in reusable coffee filter and coffee scooper, reducing the need for disposable filters and adding convenience. | Small amounts of leftover coffee often collect below the filter, causing occasional dribbling or mess if poured quickly. |
| Compatible with Melitta #2 paper filters, giving users flexibility in their filter choice. | The user manual lacks clear explanation about the moving water-pumping arm mechanism, causing some initial confusion. |
| Produces consistently great-tasting coffee with rich flavor from the first to the last cup. | The unit is very lightweight, which means it requires one hand to hold firmly while starting or stopping the machine to avoid spills. |
| Easy to clean overall, with dishwasher-safe parts simplifying maintenance. |  |
| Practical cord length allows flexible placement without clutter. |  |
| Reliable brewing performance once you understand the water-pumping arm mechanism, which is clever though not immediately intuitive. |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Amazon | $22.39  | In Stock |
| The Home Depot | $22.39  | In Stock |
| Walmart | $22.39  | In Stock |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*