# TLDR Review: Garnier Nutrisse Medium Ash Brown

*Published: 2024-10-16 | Updated: 2024-12-14 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/garnier-nutrisse-medium-ash-brown*

---

## Verdict

The Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing Hair Color Creme in 51 Medium Ash Brown has left many loyal users frustrated due to recent formula changes leading to inconsistent color outcomes. While it may still provide soft and manageable hair, the thickness of the new mixture and unreliable coloring have been significant drawbacks. If you've been a fan of Garnier in the past, it might be worth considering other options until these issues are addressed.

**Top pro:** Achieves an even color from roots to ends, with less brassiness.
**Top con:** The new ultra creme formula is significantly thicker, making it difficult to apply and mix.

## Product: Garnier Nutrisse Medium Ash Brown
**Brand:** Garnier
[Compare prices and price history on ShopSavvy](https://shopsavvy.com/products/garnier-nutrisse-medium-ash-brown)

## Pros
- Achieves an even color from roots to ends, with less brassiness.
- Leaves hair soft, shiny, and with minimal damage compared to some alternatives.

## Cons
- The new ultra creme formula is significantly thicker, making it difficult to apply and mix.
- Users report issues with color accuracy, with some experiencing a greenish or unwanted orange tint.
- Fails to cover gray hair adequately, resulting in visible roots soon after application.
- The formula does not last as long and requires more frequent application.
- Longtime loyal customers express frustration with the formula change, leading to dissatisfaction.
- Numerous complaints suggest that the color results are inconsistent, sometimes turning hair orange or leaving greenish roots.
- Customer loyalty is challenged, with many expressing a desire to switch to other brands.
- Concerns about poor performance, including the possibility of false advertising.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Achieves an even color from roots to ends, with less brassiness. | The new ultra creme formula is significantly thicker, making it difficult to apply and mix. |
| Leaves hair soft, shiny, and with minimal damage compared to some alternatives. | Users report issues with color accuracy, with some experiencing a greenish or unwanted orange tint. |
|  | Fails to cover gray hair adequately, resulting in visible roots soon after application. |
|  | The formula does not last as long and requires more frequent application. |
|  | Longtime loyal customers express frustration with the formula change, leading to dissatisfaction. |
|  | Numerous complaints suggest that the color results are inconsistent, sometimes turning hair orange or leaving greenish roots. |
|  | Customer loyalty is challenged, with many expressing a desire to switch to other brands. |
|  | Concerns about poor performance, including the possibility of false advertising. |

## Last Seen Prices

*Each price is the last one ShopSavvy observed, on 2024-12-14; it may have changed since.*

| Retailer | Price | Availability | Last seen |
|----------|-------|-------------|-----------|
| [myotcstore.com](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/bacE6RIlA6SG3Zw53a5m/offers/ogsSbDwbCHFKRiUhLTwU?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $7.31  | In Stock | 2024-12-14 (may have changed) |
| [Instacart](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/bacE6RIlA6SG3Zw53a5m/offers/iBXQ1Jl4kP7mGpVhRVJC?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $8.78  | In Stock | 2024-12-14 (may have changed) |
| [Shipt](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/bacE6RIlA6SG3Zw53a5m/offers/a48088bf-afae-d298-99e9-51e21cf33109?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $8.79  | In Stock | 2024-12-14 (may have changed) |
| [Target](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/bacE6RIlA6SG3Zw53a5m/offers/CXCLDgqzQcvheqCFx1nH?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $8.79  | In Stock | 2024-12-14 (may have changed) |
| [Walgreens](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/bacE6RIlA6SG3Zw53a5m/offers/36u2ix4hGc5BcMw3Ef3n?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $11.49  | In Stock | 2024-12-14 (may have changed) |
| [Uber Eats](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/bacE6RIlA6SG3Zw53a5m/offers/bd0c3f62-fa34-ba81-c6fa-92ac750721cd?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $13.11  | In Stock | 2024-12-14 (may have changed) |

[See every retailer and the full price history on ShopSavvy](https://shopsavvy.com/products/garnier-nutrisse-medium-ash-brown)

---

*About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data (each price shows when it was last seen).*

*Machine-readable access: append `.md` to any ShopSavvy URL, or send `Accept: text/markdown`, to get this page as Markdown. For the same catalogue as structured JSON — product lookup by barcode/ASIN/URL, live prices across retailers, and price history — see ShopSavvy's MCP server at https://shopsavvy.com/agents and the Data API at https://shopsavvy.com/data.*