# TLDR Review: Birkenstock Madrid Sandal

*Published: 2025-05-25 | Updated: 2025-07-18 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/birkenstock-madrid-sandal*

---

## Product: Birkenstock Madrid Sandal
**Brand:** Birkenstock

## Pros
- Attractive design and color, described as 'super cute' and versatile for various outfits.
- Adjustability is a bonus, especially beneficial for those with bunions.
- Suitable for wider feet, offering a good option for those struggling to find wider fits.

## Cons
- Many found the sandals uncomfortable, causing rubbing and pain.
- Issues with fit as foot tends to slide through, with toes hanging over the front.
- The buckle's dull gold appearance was disappointing compared to expectations of a shimmery gold.
- Stiffness of the shoes is a concern, as it does not seem to improve over time.
- The color and material differ from photos, appearing duller and with a grey undertone.
- Width was narrower than expected, affecting overall comfort.
- Limited options for wider foot beds, which may lead to discomfort for those needing a regular-wide fit.

## Bottom Line

While the Birkenstock Women's Madrid Big Buckle Cognac Leather Sandal is visually appealing and offers an adjustable feature, many reviewers found them uncomfortable and noted issues with fit and material contrasts. If you need a versatile, stylish sandal and have wider feet, they could be a good fit. However, if comfort is your priority, consider trying them on first or exploring other Birkenstock styles that better suit your needs.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Attractive design and color, described as 'super cute' and versatile for various outfits. | Many found the sandals uncomfortable, causing rubbing and pain. |
| Adjustability is a bonus, especially beneficial for those with bunions. | Issues with fit as foot tends to slide through, with toes hanging over the front. |
| Suitable for wider feet, offering a good option for those struggling to find wider fits. | The buckle's dull gold appearance was disappointing compared to expectations of a shimmery gold. |
|  | Stiffness of the shoes is a concern, as it does not seem to improve over time. |
|  | The color and material differ from photos, appearing duller and with a grey undertone. |
|  | Width was narrower than expected, affecting overall comfort. |
|  | Limited options for wider foot beds, which may lead to discomfort for those needing a regular-wide fit. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Burch's Shoes | $139.95  | Check |
| Footwise | $139.95  | Check |
| Shoe Mill | $139.95  | Check |
| Brown's Shoe Fit Co. | $140.00  | Check |
| Dillards - Source | $140.00  | Check |
| Glik's | $140.00  | Check |
| hsn | $140.00  | Check |
| Jildor Shoes | $140.00  | Check |
| Peltz Shoes | $140.00  | Check |
| Saks Fifth Avenue | $140.00  | Check |
| Shoooz on Park Ave | $140.00  | Check |
| Sole Provisions | $140.00  | Check |
| Stan's Fit For Your Feet | $140.00  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*