# TLDR Review: Arrow P35S Plier Stapler

*Published: 2026-03-06 | Updated: 2026-03-06 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/arrow-p35s-plier-stapler*

---

## Product: Arrow P35S Plier Stapler
**Brand:** Arrow Fastener

## Pros
- The sharper lip compared to the previous P35 model makes it easier to pierce through materials quickly.
- Effective for stapling in hard-to-reach or awkward areas, adding versatility.
- Durable and heavy-duty construction ensures reliable performance even with tough jobs.
- Ideal for closing large, thick paper bags (such as leaf bags), making it great for outdoor or compost use.
- Includes a staple puller, which is a handy improvement over older models.
- Long-term users praise its durability, with some reporting consistent use for over 30 years.
- Offers great value for the price given its build quality and heavy-duty function.
- Especially recommended if you want just one model, as it is preferred over the P35 by some users.

## Cons
- The advertised 3/8" staples do not actually fit; required staples have a larger crown (about 0.420" to 0.490"), causing confusion and difficulty sourcing compatible staples.
- The built-in staple remover feels inconvenient and potentially unsafe; many prefer a version without this attached.
- The stapler handle ring is flimsy and bends easily under pressure, so careful handling is required.
- Some users experience jamming after extended use, which decreases reliability and requires extra effort to staple through tough materials.
- Quality control appears inconsistent; some units fail prematurely.
- The confusion around staple sizing and the need for proprietary staples leads to frustration among users.
- The design can feel more complex and less user-friendly than necessary for a simple handheld stapler.

## Bottom Line

The Arrow P35S Heavy Duty Handheld Plier Stapler is a solid choice if you need a durable, heavy-duty tool for stapling thick or tough materials like paper bags or cardboard crafts. Its sharper lip and staple puller are definite upgrades, and many users swear by its long-lasting performance and value. However, be prepared to hunt for the correct oversized staples since standard 3/8" ones won’t fit, and watch out for jamming or bending handle rings with heavy use. If you want a no-nonsense, reliable stapler without staple size headaches and prefer simpler design without a built-in remover, you might want to consider other staplers, but overall this model holds up well for demanding jobs.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| The sharper lip compared to the previous P35 model makes it easier to pierce through materials quickly. | The advertised 3/8" staples do not actually fit; required staples have a larger crown (about 0.420" to 0.490"), causing confusion and difficulty sourcing compatible staples. |
| Effective for stapling in hard-to-reach or awkward areas, adding versatility. | The built-in staple remover feels inconvenient and potentially unsafe; many prefer a version without this attached. |
| Durable and heavy-duty construction ensures reliable performance even with tough jobs. | The stapler handle ring is flimsy and bends easily under pressure, so careful handling is required. |
| Ideal for closing large, thick paper bags (such as leaf bags), making it great for outdoor or compost use. | Some users experience jamming after extended use, which decreases reliability and requires extra effort to staple through tough materials. |
| Includes a staple puller, which is a handy improvement over older models. | Quality control appears inconsistent; some units fail prematurely. |
| Long-term users praise its durability, with some reporting consistent use for over 30 years. | The confusion around staple sizing and the need for proprietary staples leads to frustration among users. |
| Offers great value for the price given its build quality and heavy-duty function. | The design can feel more complex and less user-friendly than necessary for a simple handheld stapler. |
| Especially recommended if you want just one model, as it is preferred over the P35 by some users. |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Hardwick & Sons | $29.99  | Check |
| zorotools.com | $36.09  | Check |
| Amazon | $38.13  | Check |
| Tenaquip | $60.40  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*